Skip to content

OXO Good Grips 2-Piece Plastic Cutting Board Set: problems, parts and running costs

Checked: 2026-10-30

Summary

The two-board polypropylene set (7.25×10.75 in Prep Board and 9×12.9 in Everyday Board) develops knife marks with normal use; the larger board can feel bouncy under heavy downward force and its non-slip feet may need a damp towel for full stability. No electricity, subscriptions or proprietary consumables are required. Replacement cost is roughly $7–$14 per year depending on how often the boards wear out. At the typical $27–$29 retail price it is fair value; $25 or less is a good deal and $20 or less is excellent.

Common problems and fixes

Parts and consumables

Yearly running cost

Electricity and subscription costs are $0 per year — the boards have no power components or subscription. Scheduled proprietary consumables: $0 per year — none specified. Cleaning uses normal hot water, dish soap and optional food-safe sanitizer (USDA suggests 1 tbsp unscented bleach per gallon of water); no mandatory proprietary cleaner or conditioner. No representative annual cleaning-supply cost published. Replacement scenario (illustrative, not a required schedule): a new exact set costs $27.99 (OXO, Home Depot, October 2026). If a household replaces both boards every two years, equivalent purchase expense is about $14/year; every four years, about $7/year. If only the smaller board is worn, the single Prep Board is $14.99. No study establishes a universal 2- or 4-year lifetime; replace based on condition as USDA recommends. [6][7][8]

When it is a good buy

US retail snapshots checked October 2026, exact SKU 11284600, before taxes and shipping:

Observed normal advertised US price: about $27–$29. Editorial thresholds: $20 or less new is an excellent deal; $21–$25 good; $26–$29 standard fair value; above $30 unattractive while OXO and large retailers display $27.99. [6][7][9][10][11]

Alternatives:

  1. Figmint 2-Piece Nonslip Recycled-Poly Cutting Board Set (Target, black) — $18.00 in stock October 2026. Two non-slip, dishwasher-safe boards with juice channels and tapered grips; at least 20% recycled plastic per retailer. Better if budget is under $20 or you prefer darker color. The tested OXO set has stronger documented independent editorial coverage; no same-method head-to-head longevity test verified for Figmint. [12]
  2. Mainstays 2-Piece Nonslip Recycled-Poly Cutting Board Set (Walmart, blue) — $10.97, two boards approx 8.5×11 in and 10×14 in, dishwasher-safe. Better for lowest initial cost and larger surfaces. Product material and exact grip differ; not proof Mainstays lasts as long or offers the same secure feel as OXO. [13]
  3. Epicurean Kitchen Series 2-Piece Board Set — $60.95 manufacturer-direct (October 2026), made in USA from paper composite, 11.5×9×1/4 in + 14.5×11.25×1/4 in, dishwasher-safe. Manufacturer offers a lifetime warranty and NSF certification. Better for someone willing to pay substantially more for larger cutting surfaces and paper composite instead of polypropylene. GearLab rated Epicurean composites very durable but noted the harder material can be less friendly to some knives. [4][14]

Sources