All American 1930 Model 921: problems, parts and running costs
Checked: 2026-11-10
Summary
The All American 1930 Model 921 can develop lid seepage when new and requires yearly replacement of the overpressure plug and pressure dial. Typical owners spend about $89.75 per year on safety parts and canning lids, making it a good buy at $400 or less for those who want a no-gasket design.
Common problems and fixes
- Lid seepage when new — new machined metal-to-metal seals can leak steam until they bed in; follow manual inspection and contact support if normal pressure cannot be maintained. [2]
- Sticking lid/vacuum lock — leaving regulator weight in place after pressure reaches zero can create vacuum; manual provides safe opening instructions. [2]
- Potential blocked vent — September 2025 owner reported dial climbing to 20 psi while 10 psi weight didn’t jiggle; turn heat off, let cool completely, inspect before reuse. [2][17]
- Safety plug annual replacement — manufacturer specifies #2040 plug replacement every 12 months or if hard/worn/deformed; deployed plug must never be reused. [2][3][5]
- Pressure dial yearly replacement — manufacturer recommends #72 gauge yearly replacement despite weighted system; costs $24.95 direct. [3][4]
- Weight/stove incompatibility — 15-3/8-inch exterior bottom and 22-24 lb empty load may exceed cooktop burner-size/weight constraints. [1][2][10]
- Six wing-nut assembly complexity — requires even tightening in opposite pairs; takes more time than twist-lock lids. [2][4]
Parts and consumables
- #2040 Overpressure Plug — $4.95 direct (November 2026); replace every 12 months or if cracked/hardened, immediately after deployment. [2][3][5]
- #72 Dial Pressure/Steam Gauge — $24.95 direct (November 2026); manufacturer recommends yearly replacement. [3][4]
- #68 Three-position Regulator Weight — $19.95 direct; inspect before use, replace if damaged/lost. [2][3][5]
- #69 Vent Pipe — $19.95 direct; inspect before each run for obstructions, replace if worn/blocked. [2][3][5]
- #151 Rack — $14.95 each direct; two included with new 921, additional racks for bent/lost units. [1][3]
- #64 Phenolic Wing Nut — $9.95 each direct; inspect for damage/cracks, replace when compromised. [2][3]
- Pressure Canner Repair Kit — $84.95 direct; includes two wing-nut assemblies, regulator, vent pipe, gauge, plug, booklet and instructions. [6]
- Ball 12-count regular-mouth canning lids — $3.99 at Target (November 2026, about $0.33/lid); single-use per processing batch. [19]
Yearly running cost
Typical owner spends $89.75 per year following manufacturer recommendations: $29.90 for annual safety parts (plug $4.95 + gauge $24.95) plus $59.85 for 180 flat lids at $3.99 per 12-count pack. No reliable measured energy consumption data available for exact model across stove types.
When it is a good buy
- Pleasant Hill Grain: Original 921 at $449.95, in stock, 3-5 business days shipping. [9]
- Red Hill General Store: Silver 921 at $449.95, marked in stock (confirm cart configuration). [10]
- Eartheasy: 921 at $449.95, free shipping messaging. [18]
- Factory outlet: Cosmetically blemished 921 at $409.96 (out of stock, final sale). [11]
Good buy at $400 or less for new, authentic, full-warranty 921. Fair at $425-$450 if stove compatible and gasket-free seal matters. Avoid above $475-$500 unless appearance justifies it; consider Presto 01781 at $185.99. [1][9][10][14]
Alternatives:
- Presto 23-Quart 01781 at $185.99 — better for first-time canners or low budgets with acceptable gasket replacement and dial maintenance.
- All American 1930 Model 915 at $399.95 — better for tight spaces or quart-focused batches.
- All American 1930 Model 925 at $499.95 — better for extra vertical room but similar jar capacity to 921.
Sources
- All American 1930 Model 921 official product page
- All American 1930 pressure cooker manual (2022)
- All American 1930 replacement parts catalogue
- All American 1930 Canning Hub maintenance
- Pleasant Hill Grain 921 listing
- Red Hill General Store 921 listing
- Eartheasy 921 listing
- Factory outlet 921 listing
- Reddit r/Canning: September 2025 regulator issue
- Target Ball canning lids pricing